Police in NL to Lead Workplace Investigations

Police in NL to Lead Workplace Investigations

July 24, 2018

Newfoundland and Labrador’s provincial police service, the Royal Newfoundland Constabulary (the “RNC”), has recently begun working with the Calgary Police Service to change how investigations of workplace incidents will be instituted. It officially announced that it will be conducting criminal investigations at every workplace where a serious injury or death occurs. This new protocol differs from the role played by the RNC the in past which would generally see police securing the scene so that Occupational Health and Safety (“OHS”) could conduct its investigation. The announcement comes after a recent fatality at a construction site in St. John’s where the RNC have publicized taking the lead in the investigation rather than leaving it to provincial OHS officials.

This new protocol has not been seen before in Atlantic Canada. In New Brunswick, Nova Scotia and Prince Edward Island, OHS is the primary investigator to all workplace incidents and only defer to police agencies when required to do so.

The RNC cited the “Westray Amendments” as the reason for the shift.  Bill C-45, or the “Westray Bill,” originated out of Nova Scotia following a Royal Commission of Inquiry established to investigate the tragic 1992 disaster at the Westray coal mine. An explosion at the mine resulted in the death of 26 workers.  In that case, the prosecution of two managers of the mine was abandoned. The “Westray Bill”, which amended the Criminal Code, established new rules for attributing criminal liability to corporations, their representatives and those who direct the work of others.

The “Westray Amendments” are not new law and in fact, have been in force since 2004.  Readers may recall the well-known case of R v Metron Construction Corporation, 2013 ONCA 541 (“Metron”) which involved the tragic deaths of four workers (and serious injury of another) who fell from the fourteenth floor of a high rise building in Toronto in 2009. The workers fell while they were conducting exterior repairs from an overloaded swing stage, a type of suspended platform. In that case, the employer, Metron Construction, pled guilty to criminal negligence causing death, as set out in the Criminal Code, and received a fine of $200,000.00 at trial. The fine was more than tripled to $750,000.00 by the Ontario Court of Appeal. Metron Construction’s project manager was sentenced to 3.5 years in jail (discussed in one of our earlier publications), a decision which was recently upheld by the Ontario Court of Appeal.  Furthermore, Metron Construction’s director pled guilty to four counts under Ontario’s OHS legislation.

What About OHS Legislation?

In addition to the Criminal Code, OHS legislation continues to impose legal obligations on employers with respect to occupational health and safety. Both statutes operate independently and, as can be seen by the Metron case referenced above, employers and those directing the workforce can be charged under either the Criminal Code or OHS legislation. While OHS legislation sets out imprisonment as a possible penalty, a breach of the legislation has typically resulted in a fine.

Lessons for Employers

As noted above, the Criminal Code provisions imposing criminal liability on employers with respect to workplace incidents is not new. The RNC’s recent announcement however, should serve to remind employers of their legal obligation to safeguard the health and safety of their employees. There is no time like the present for employers to be proactive in reviewing their existing health and safety programs and policies and revising where necessary.

Related Articles

Secretly Recording Workplace Conversations Can Result in Termination

In recent years, there has been an increase in the prevalence of employees secretly recording conversations in the workplace. While it is not unlawful for a conversation to be recorded when only one person is aware that the recording is being taken, the undisclosed recording of conversations can raise privacy concerns. The recent decision of […]

read more

How to Prepare for Coronavirus in the Workplace

As global concerns are on the rise, and in light of yesterday’s news of the first presumptive case of Coronavirus in Atlantic Canada, employers in this region should consider how to respond if the Coronavirus presents within the workplace. What is Coronavirus? COVID-19, commonly referred to as Coronavirus, is a virus which may cause symptoms […]

read more

New Occupational Health and Safety Regulations in New Brunswick: Addressing Workplace Harassment and Violence

New Brunswick has introduced new regulations under the General Regulations – Occupational Health and Safety Act (“OHSA”) aimed at identifying and preventing workplace violence and harassment (the “New Regulations”). The New Regulations will take effect April 1, 2019. The New Regulations have been introduced to address problematic workplace conduct, including bullying, physical violence, verbal abuse, […]

read more
view all
Cox & Palmer publications are intended to provide information of a general nature only and not legal advice. The information presented is current to the date of publication and may be subject to change following the publication date.